How Do Store Brands and Private Labels Impact Profit Margins in Pet Food?

The pet food industry has seen a significant shift with the rise of store brands and private label pet food products. Major retailers, including grocery chains, warehouse clubs, and specialty pet stores, are investing heavily in private label pet food to capture market share from national brands. This shift affects profit margins, pricing strategies, and competitive dynamics across the industry.

Store brands and private label pet food impact profit margins by offering higher margins for retailers while creating price pressure on national brands. Private label products typically yield profit margins between 30% and 50%, compared to 20%–35% for national brands. The cost savings in marketing, distribution, and branding allow retailers to sell private label pet food at lower prices while maintaining profitability. However, national brands must adjust by investing in innovation, premium offerings, and direct-to-consumer strategies to stay competitive.

This article explores how private labels impact pet food profit margins, compares profitability between private labels and national brands, and identifies strategies for pet food companies to compete effectively.

1. What Are Store Brands and Private Label Pet Food?

Private label pet food refers to products manufactured by third-party companies but sold under a retailer’s brand name. These products are typically more affordable than national brands but offer similar nutritional value.

Types of Private Label Pet Food:

• Economy Private Label – Budget-friendly, basic pet food competing with low-cost national brands.
• Premium Private Label – Higher-quality formulas targeting pet owners looking for natural, grain-free, or organic options.
• Super-Premium Private Label – Specialty diets, such as organic, high-protein, and prescription-based pet food.

Major retailers such as Walmart (Pure Balance), Chewy (American Journey), and Petco (WholeHearted) have successfully launched their own private label pet food lines.

2. Profit Margins: Private Label vs. National Brands

Private label pet food offers a significant profitability advantage for retailers compared to carrying national brands. Below is a comparison of typical profit margins:

Why Do Private Labels Have Higher Margins?

1. Lower Marketing Costs – Retailers rely on store placement and customer loyalty rather than national advertising campaigns.
2. Lower Distribution Expenses – Private label pet food is exclusively sold in-store, reducing supply chain complexities.
3. Control Over Pricing – Retailers can adjust pricing dynamically, unlike national brands that rely on fixed wholesale agreements.
4. Contract Manufacturing – Retailers outsource production to pet food manufacturers, reducing operational costs.

Impact on National Brands

• Price Pressure: National brands must reduce prices or differentiate products to remain competitive.
• Retailer Negotiation Power: As private labels grow, retailers demand better pricing from national brands, squeezing their margins.
• Reduced Shelf Space: Private label pet food often replaces national brand products on shelves.

3. Private Label Pricing Strategies and Consumer Behavior

Private label pet food brands leverage competitive pricing strategies while maintaining premium positioning.

Consumer Perception:

• Trust in Store Brands: More consumers view private labels as high-quality and reliable, especially when marketed as premium options.
• Budget-Conscious Shoppers: Consumers looking for savings switch to private labels, especially during economic downturns.
• Loyalty to Retailers: Customers buying private label pet food develop stronger loyalty to the retailer, increasing repeat purchases.

4. How Private Labels Affect the Overall Pet Food Market

Market Share Growth of Private Label Pet Food

Private label pet food is gaining market share, particularly in the premium and super-premium segments.

By 2025, private labels are projected to capture over 25% of the total pet food market, increasing competition with national brands.

Who Benefits from Private Labels?

• Retailers: Higher margins, control over pricing, increased customer retention.
• Manufacturers: Some national brands produce private label pet food, benefiting from increased production volume.
• Consumers: Lower prices for comparable quality products.

5. How National Brands Can Compete Against Private Labels

To maintain profit margins and market share, national pet food brands must innovate and differentiate their products.

A. Invest in Premium and Functional Pet Food

• Specialized Formulas: Brands can offer organic, veterinary, and breed-specific diets that private labels struggle to replicate.
• Sustainable and Ethical Sourcing: Transparency in ingredient sourcing and eco-friendly packaging appeals to premium consumers.

B. Strengthen Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) Sales

• Online Subscriptions: Custom meal plans and recurring deliveries can increase customer retention.
• Exclusive E-Commerce Products: Brands can introduce limited-edition products sold only through their website.

C. Leverage Branding and Marketing

• Vet-Endorsed Products: Aligning with veterinarians and pet health professionals increases trust and credibility.
• Influencer and Social Media Marketing: Collaborating with pet influencers enhances brand loyalty and premium positioning.

D. Expand Distribution Beyond Retailers

• Selling directly through e-commerce minimizes retailer control over pricing.
• Partnering with boutique pet stores differentiates premium brands from mass-market private labels.

Conclusion: The Impact of Private Labels on Pet Food Profit Margins

Private label pet food is disrupting the industry by offering higher margins for retailers and lower prices for consumers. While store brands typically maintain 30% - 50% profit margins, national brands are facing increasing pressure to adjust their pricing and marketing strategies.

To remain competitive, national pet food brands must focus on:

1. Premiumization – Offering functional, organic, and high-protein formulas.
2. DTC Expansion – Reducing dependence on retailers.
3. Brand Differentiation – Strengthening marketing, vet partnerships, and social media presence.

The future of pet food profitability will depend on how well brands navigate private label competition, consumer expectations, and pricing strategies.

Need Help Maximizing Pet Food Profitability?

Our experts specialize in market strategy, pricing optimization, and supply chain efficiency to help pet food brands stay competitive. Contact us today for a consultation!